All things considered, they offer the most for your money. I got in when it was syncing via Dropbox and iCloud, and it worked perfectly fine. That pushes me even further towards going that route. This popular service is available across many platforms including Windows, Android, iOS and Mac, just to mention a few. Try FREE for 14 days Try FREE for 14 days Try FREE for 14 days All 1Password accounts include Unlimited Devices As a Vim user I will happily admit that Sublime is significantly faster in some key areas of daily use. This happens with your credit card for instance which is typically not linked to a particular url. The release introduces a significant design revamp and improvements to Watchtower, the feature that helps you weed out weak passwords. Their old client was super easy for non-technical users and groups (just enter Dropbox credentials, etc). As long as billing for your subscription is allowed to continue, your initial subscription for 1Password 7 should carry over and fund your 1Password account. Are you looking to make a prototype, or are you trying to go to prod with mission critical data? I used the migration as a point in time to clean up my vault and have enjoyed a completely clean password manager ever since. Suppose you tell your employer that you're taking a 1-week vacation. > Can you quantify the "needless development churn and hassle for both customers and our support team" in some way? _If_ they obtain a copy of my password file. It can be used poorly. psst, for many of us 1password of old not having any native syncing functionality WAS A FEATURE. I stored everything in KeePass, recovery keys, TOTP seeds, sensitive documents and notes. macOS has been less shy about deprecating old APIs and forcing software updates. You were given a choice. Well, I don't use the desktop app that much, mostly for organizing items in a batch. Not a good idea to leave your sole copy on a machine you don't have full control over. iOS Open and unlock 1Password 7. If at the end of the day my home server breaks and I want to get on and watch Amazon Prime/Netflix/whatever I still can with a hosted password manager. The funny thing is, they were doing just fine for years with just their own money. If you're comfortable with a snapshot w/o updates, then by all means buy once, but I think coming to terms with the demands of ongoing support also means coming to terms with continuing to support the product in some way. Where they going out of business before offering stand alone licenses? Hi, long-time user, customer, and word-of-mouth recommender of 1Password for the nine years my Hacker News account has been active (give or take a few months). Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. But, of course, that's a ridiculous hypothetical not really grounded in reality. The hatred comes from their proliferation. Maybe I'm missing something, but i pay for those teams with my client purchases. Furthermore, you can find the "Troubleshooting Login Issues" section which can answer your unresolved problems and equip you with a lot of . I don't _want_ the ongoing development. If the people using the app are content with the features/quality and the resources it uses, why does it matter so much, especially to a third party like armchair engineers on HN, if it was built natively, on Electron, or CrappierFrameworkThatWillEventuallyReplaceElectron? > Click this link and paste in your TOTP secret because we need to verify your identity: https://1passsword.com/2fa-verify/, > if you think some rando can _phish_ a TOTP secret. I'm not saying it's impossible, just one of the least likely things to happen. Instead, the import was better than perfect: a bunch of accounts that wouldn't autofill in lastpass magically started to autofill after being imported into bitwarden. This! I don't know the answer. I get why some people have prejudice against any Electron app as resource hog - but even if I would ever experience that, I would still wait what this specific app would do a and feel like - I am on the 8 beta on Windows and would never go back to v7. Do Windows, macOS and Linux seem "consistent"? Your new subscription will begin immediately. Not too much time, honestly. Choose Help > Tools > Migrate standalone vaults to account. Software as a service is a good concept for something that is truly changing all the time, but I find it absurd that a Photoshop subscription or a huge IDE cost as much as these utilities thst used to be shareware in the past. but look at something like Adobe CC, what exactly does moving from a purchase to a subscription benefit me? same here this is when i switched to bitwarden and haven't looked back! If you are saying 2x engineers on electron complete tasks faster than 1x on electron and 1x on native, you are basically agreeing with OPs take. This was about a year ago. Thats it. > $4.99/month for 5 people is affordable. I would, if I felt the need. I'm not aware of any other big name cloud storage providers that offer support for standard protocols. So I learned early on that people unreasonably expect support for no additional cost. Yep, long time 1password user and recommender. > requiring two separate teams of platform developers for every feature we needed to implement. For lower powered devices, this becomes an issue. You're of course free to use whatever software you want or do whatever you want. If that app happens to be useful enough for others to use it, even better, that person just solved what could have potentially been a big deal for that user. I can understand your frustrations about Electron and our subscription-based model, but I hope you find my explanation reasonable. If you have exported a 1PUX or 1PIF file from 1Password, you can import them to 1Password. Thats reasonable logic but for me with a company subscription and previously having been an individual purchaser with my backup in iCloud rather than on 1 pass servers, it doesnt really tilt the balance - I also hate electron with a passion and will be looking to stay on 7 for as long as possible with a high likelihood of shifting to a different provider due to the forced shift to cloud storage after this. I know the standalone version of 1Password 7 exists, but I tried to find the price yesterday and gave up after a few minutes of poking around. (Or more realistically, you can watch with something like Little Snitch or WireShark to ensure it isn't happening.) If this article didn't answer your question, contact 1Password Support. There are many password management software programs available today. 1. Sadly switching password managers, especially if you share with a family, is really painful. These could either be synced through their website (1password account vaults) or saved to disk locally (local vaults). I support 1PW using its money to grow in enterprise and on other platforms, but not at the expense of the customers who made 1PW successful in the first place., This is a huge step back in all aspects sadly, added xmanuw. If you can convince someone to provide you their password, it's highly likely you'll also be able to convince them to also provide you their time-based OTP. Agreed. Hope that helps. Under License in the 1Password 7 app, there will be an option to purchase a standalone license . There are no new features needed, it's a password manager. I just wish they were cheaper and more accessible > But also, in such setup, the security benefit of 2FA/OTP codes are negligible at best since there are no conditions under which only one factor could be compromised without also having the other factor leaked (assuming you're using unique passwords for each identity, which is the entire point of a password manager). Okay, I have a suggestion: drop Electron and keep supporting the native app you have. The upcoming 1Password 8, currently in early access, shifts the password manager to the cross-platform Electron development framework. I love that KeePass works with pretty much whatever sync service you prefer. If I had to pull out my phone every time I wanted to use 2FA, I for sure would not be so liberal to turn it on for all the "low value" properties the way I do now. 1Password doesn't offer a free reduced-feature version, true. The paid plan support OTP token and allow big file so you can embed stuff like google cloud json token file. > they're referring to the time when that was on their site and people overwhelmingly chose the subscription. I dont have issues with the URL, theres lots of options for how the matching works. USD$3 may be a cup of coffee in the US, however in Singapore it can buy 5 cups of coffee . Keylogger, Ive left 3 years of no-income life as a student, and thatll be a whooping USD$108 or SGD$150 . \_()_/, Fwiw, 1Password isn't nuking 1P7 or existing local vaults. They demanded support in return for their one payment. But that doesnt make VS Code shit. It is native, what are you talking about? I believe there's barely no benefit to setting up a TOTP 2FA for those accounts if you're going to store the backup codes/token seed along with the password in the same vault. There's enough access in there to remove the 2FA on all of my accounts even if you didn't have the codes. I'd love to do this. So they made their own sync service and hid the version that would do local-only files so that only the dedicated users who really want to do that would find it and use it. It's why we have a pilot and copilot on planes. i use syncthing to take care of the replication. Oh and I do manual backups to SD cards just to be sure every month. Youre not limited to just one. Maybe Im just too old-school, thinking that when paying for software its yours. Even the app only need a small set of its features, the entire thing is running just like a virtual machine. They hide the standard version on the website, but the specific picture they show in-app[0] is pretty clear about the license option, so if it's 97% of people choosing the subscription via that screen i'd believe them. I also paid for a non subscription version and I also feel like I was forced to upgrade to the subscription. I've left 3 years of no-income life as a student, and that'll be a whooping USD$108 or SGD$150 3 Reply I probably spend $500-1000 every year just upgrading a certain few software packages that charge for a new version every time a new macOS comes out, and I hate it. I hate Electron as much as the next guy, but man have I been enjoying Obsidian. Hopefully the app is as performant as they can possible get from Electron. I am a 1PW subscription user and am happy with the product (however, seeing they are moving to Electron means that is very subject to change). > I'm curious about how you see the attack surface increasing when using 1Password. Any child can hack a UI together in HTML but there's a reason no one (usually) pays for that. AFAIK Keepass has issues there while bitwarden (IIRC) supports it completely. This is a big announcement that I'll have to chew on to understand what this means. Same. And if youre adamant youre giving up on 1Password, allow us to recommend Dashlane, the official password manager of Cult of Mac. -->if this happens to someone even once, the hate can be visceral afterword. Man in the middle attack, 1P7 doesn't even let you keyboard navigate to the Generate Password button for goodness sake - something that I was able to do in every version up to that point. Come back and you have to find the credit card again and then copy the next bit then go paste and when you come back you're once again presented with the full list so you have to go find the credit card again. Sure, happy to elaborate on that! Over the past few years, we've been working on consolidating 1Password's business logic into a single Rust-powered core that could be shared across all our apps. Every week you'll get tech tips, in-depth reviews, and insightful news analysis for discerning Apple users. Not impressed by EN version, and have only heard negatives about Slack and others (which I dont use anyway). Tap Delete Vault. How often do we have new versions of iOS or macOS? I don't know how I missed this. Keep in mind that you'll have to purchase a subscription . The site was confusing as hell, and it seemed purposely so, > Saying that "customers voted with their wallet" and chose subscriptions is disingenous. When I'm on Linux, I want my apps to behave like a Linux app. I have stopped using the discord desktop app and exclusively use the website now. I've never had a single issue at all with them, and it always just works which for me is the single most important feature. This was the top reported issue with 1Password 8 on Windows so we'd love to hear from you if it solved the connection issues for your setup. Choose Account > Sign in to another account and enter your account details. You've ruined what used to be the best password manager on any platform. The issues are twofold: 1Password 8 will become subscription-only, thus removing the option to buy it outright; and; they've moved the app over to something called Electron. I just tried to do this after comparing the features that I use and what I'm paying 1p vs. the bw rate. Take a look at the items marked new in the changelog. In this review, however, we'll be talking about 1Password, one of the best password managers utilized by millions of users worldwide. and I hate Electron apps. Want Syncthing instead of Nextcloud? Add other dark patterns like the extension being 1PX only by default and doesn't work with standalone. Go for it, there's nothing stopping them. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. I use Bitwarden for shared passwords with my family (using an Organisation). And that's why I only use community maintained software with no telemetry or "data driven decisions.". It just makes the developers job way easier. Except, you didn't need to roll your own. I have engineering software programs that are a decade old that still run fine on my Windows 10 machine. > The point of using 2FA for me is to protect me against my password being compromised since it's a long_lived access key. It's in the release notes, it was on the site, and it was in the forums. > Http (not https) traffic sniffing, > (assuming you're using unique passwords for each identity, which is the entire point of a password manager). Date of experience: October 29, 2022. > If my password vault is compromised it's game over anyway. I would like to congratulate the team on the release today. Hi. Read our Cookie Policy. Very likely (also kind of sadly) most users will stay with them. How? edit: apparently 8 will be electron-based. But hey, I'm the type of person that considered a Gentoo machine running Fluxbox far more useful than the very polished MacOS. macOS, Windows and Android. If 1Password doesn't ask you to add your account to the app, open and unlock 1Password for Mac, then choose Account > "Sign in to Account" and enter your account details. why does 1password need ongoing support? I don't know how to feel about switching to electron. As far as I'm concerned, the SLA of $10 shareware I volunteered to pay for is "whatever the developer is willing and able to provide." Definitely. UI consistency between different operating systems is NOT a user-focussed feature. Migrating your data requires 1Password 7. Can you share the link? You've got to decide what is the biggest risk for your own personal use cases. I don't quite see why free bug fixes/minor features + paid major upgrades model should be any different from subscription model for developers. You haven't fixed the "people are assholes" problem. I've begun transitioning to Notion because of it. 1Password 8 is currently available for download on the Apple App Store (opens in new tab) and the Google Play Store (opens in new tab). 2. I got rid of two of them Evernote for exactly the same reason. I've had three software subscriptions until this year, mostly begrudgingly CreativeCloud, Evernote and 1password. But my wife can't do this. That goes especially for anything I open often, or for anything it'd be convenient or necessary to leave running most or all of the time. Im extremely disappointed to see this turn into yet another sub-native browser-in-a-window experience. There is a lot posted about 1Password 8 and the negatives compared to 1Password7. Can even live with subscription (its just forking out a few bucks more), can even live with electron - at least a Linux client will be avaialable rightaway, but why no local store, Dropbox sync was working perfectly ! This feature was a game changer for me and my Mac mini without Touch ID or Face ID, I didnt know this is a thing Ill have to look into it - thanks. I use it and pay an annual subscription and have no issues. Potentially. Bitwarden has slowly been adding the features I wanted when I had left Lastpass - and at this point it just works for my workflow. I recently visited my friend from our programming club who saved these letters and was reminded a couple people wrote additional angry letters years after paying for the shareware. Pick one computer or mobile device that has your 1Password data. As a programmer myself, I do understand the rationale of charging for upgrades. Parent commenter can delete this message to hide from others. Official subreddit. We now pay the subscription, a tad begrudgingly, but I have to admit 1Password overall does a great job. Thank you. OP said electron = bad and you should be ashamed of using it because its helping propagate it's usage when its a cancer. $4.99/month for family and $2.99/month for user is entirely reasonable! This makes losing local vault support an even bigger cause for alarm: > After you remove a family members account, they cant sign in to 1Password, which means: > They lose all the items in their Private vault. Also I think the "head" of the family can reset passwords of the other accounts More pragmatically, that's a prime opportunity for some to make a nasty divorce quite a bit more nasty. i thought most users were talking about personal use here? But they won't let me. But then you become lazy and greedy and want 1 size fits all. So either the password is sent to their servers anyway or a malicious actor could simply update the client to do so. Maybe a little of column A and column B, honestly. Internet users looking to boost their online security should always have a password manager app handy. LoginAsk is here to help you access 1password Standalone Price quickly and handle each specific case you encounter. The ones who should stop spreading misinformation regarding the forced subscription all seem to be working for AgileBits. > but the fact that they seem to have willy-nilly removed local vaults does. However, would definitely recommend KeePassXC for desktop. Log in to sites and fill forms securely with a single click and much more. I imagine I am not alone with such a sense of disappointment. Apps for Mac, iOS, Windows, Android, and Linux are all included. - conflict-less sync; with KeepassXC, I learned to live with keepass-diff, once the inevitable sync conflict happens. I have no particular qualms with paying for software whether as a one-time purchase or a subscription. For many of us, our Apple Watch offers glanceable access to the time and date, notifications, and information about our health and wellbeing. My passwords automatically sync between devices without any interaction. KUALA LUMPUR: Bank Muamalat Malaysia Bhd will revise its standard base rate (SBR), base rate (BR), and base financing rate (BFR) by 25 basis points each with effect from Nov 8, 2022 . I totally agree that primitives are some of the least important parts of choosing password managers, but what I like about KeePass is that you can use Argon2 as the password derivation function and specify your hardness factors. The browser integration is Crap though especially compared to 1Password. This makes me sad, tweeted Curtis Herbert. I too am a bit reluctant to Electron. I'd vastly prefer to be able to do 'bring your own storage' but for that price I don't really see a problem with that being a "you can do that, but you pay the same subscription price anyway" feature. I'd be quite happy to pay a developer to continue to maintain an older version of their software. Well, Im saving $5/month so Ill tell you in a few decades. Creator AgileBits calls it our best Mac app to date. Its user interface has been reworked to make it easier to use, with more information at your fingertips. Also the only affiliation I have with 1Password is I have a friend I recently learned works for them, otherwise I'm just a customer. Trust that the company which provides something you need is far more likely to continue to be around. YERUSHALAYIM Prime Minister Yair Lapid visited the Karish offshore . A password manager doesn't need frequent updates. That being said, this is still in an early access stage, so there are bound to be hiccups and UI issues that need to be resolved. We want native UI. I saw something mentioned about self-hosted vaults. 1Password 8 will remove support for local vaults. and gotten friends and family to do the same, but I think Im done when 7 stops working. Most people here could trivially roll a prototype grade password manager in pretty limited time. Way too often, automatic upgrades silently break my existing software, take away functionality or introduce new bugs. Most record types (software license, wireless router, documents, drivers licenses, email accounts, membership, passports, maybe more) dont exist in Bitwarden. If the servers go down you'll never lose access to anything. It does not, that is why there is KeePassXC and other alternatives. 'Breech' of the site and realisation they host their passwords in clear text on an unsecured db online. If 1Password doesnt ask you to move your data, tap Settings > Advanced > Migrate data to 1Password account, then tap your account and tap Move data. If 1Password doesnt ask you to move your data, tap Settings > Advanced > Migrate Data to Your Account, then tap your account and tap Move Data. It removes a source of architectural complexity, and most users aren't looking for local storage anyway. Personally, I use it with Google Drive and it even works with Android/iOS clients. 1Password fills iframes too (though maybe only for cards, not sure). The password manager that's as beautiful and simple. You can click and drag the clipping box to move it or click and drag in the bottom right corner to resize it. Since it is important that my wife can use the same database even if we have one iCloud-account each. One could argue that their support team has handled this change unskilfully and that Agilebits should have hired a larger and more skilled support team before having a way to pay that team. I tried installing the (Linux) desktop client, which exports to a different file format from the one, single 1p format listed as supported by bw. I feel like these small, affordable, services are just whittling away the Unix philosophy of do one small thing well. Also I see your reply has been downvoted enough to become grey. Edit to add this small addendum: It just really bothers me on an emotional level to constantly run into this juxtaposition as a user of software/hardware: liking a product but being extremely disappointed in the company offering it. Electron is a tool. What's your experience building security systems? On the other hand, if it means my wife (on Windows) gets feature parity with my macOS client, that would be good. I've been using KeePass (KeePassXC and similar) for years. They have been talking about this for years. It was not done willy-nilly. +1 for bitwarden. Just to clarify: when I said that a SwiftUI version would cause hassle for customers, I was referring to how releasing two separate versions of our app - one in Electron, and one in SwiftUI - would be confusing for non-technical users. There's no way I'm giving up breakglass access and risking locking myself out of my accounts permanently or while I'm on road if I lose my phone. 1Password subscription billing is fair, flexible, and easy to understand: Get all the 1Password apps for free. after trying the app out for 5 minutes I uninstalled it again this rewrite looks and feels like cheap non native crap and doesnt improve on any pain points but introduced loads more new ones.. Many 1Password users claim they will now consider switching to other password management solutions. The different UI changes wouldnt bother me after living with them for a while I imagine. Sure, a local-only password manager doesn't need a subscription, and solutions such as KeePassXC demonstrate this quite well (as a user of it myself! 1Passwords dark mode has also been improved, as has item editing. I try to support projects like that too. I've been holding off on the subscription transition because I would derive zero value from switching to subscription but I'd gain a monthly payment I didn't have before. Their browser extensions can be used without it, and they're awesome. Almost everything from early iPhone OS to 12, and from 12 onwards worked ok, even with major resolution changes. Or will 1Password 7 users be given free upgrade to 1Password 8 like from 1Password 4 to 6? There are ways you could make a vault compromise not mean a complete/irreversible takeover, but that would either give up breakglass access as you say or add complexity and reduce availability. I don't see the difference between this and any other password manager now. no issue. > Over the shoulder attack. Grab $20 off Family Subscriptions. 1Password on Linux is electron, and works wonderfully. Why not? 5 years ago 2017. Phishing attack, I imagine it's because you made a blanket claim about spin and dark patterns without any supporting evidence. But that does make it easier. I'm not talking about change for the sake of change. yeah the interface is crap compared to 1password but i do find a bit of comfort that even though it's not the best interface it's fully opensource unlike 1password. If every single utility and app start charging $3 or $5 per month then it becomes a problem. I have a shared family KeePass database as well. Let me decrypt them using a password i specify. A subscription is required, with individual pricing set at $3.99 per month for unlimited access . The consumer-friendly option is to let the consumer decide if they want upgrades. I'm in the same boat. Strongbox supports both, Secrets use iCloud. It does seem like an interesting and useful project, though there are also other more popular alternatives like Caddy: https://caddyserver.com/ (even though their V2 not being backwards compatible was a tad annoying), Oh, and some people also have pretty good luck with software like Traefik: https://traefik.io/traefik/. That's your mum and dad and other very likely non-techie people. It's absolutely incredible to me that people ignore one of the biggest sides of the argument for pre-baked, user friendly products like 1Password: usability for as many people as possible. It also assumes you don't want the features in the paid version of Bitwarden, so it's not an apples-to-apples comparison. Eventually they will stop supporting them but that'll just mean at some point in the future a MacOS/firefox/chrome update will break the existing app and they won't fix it. I'm a feature developer for 1Password, and I want to clarify a few things. Nobody is forcing you to use Electron or any app built with it if you don't want to. It's just that any changes you make locally or changes made on dropbox.com cannot be synced until your connection is back. As anticipated and appreciated it is very much the same as the Linux app. We have been working on these changes long before we received any form of outside investments. December 31, 2022. But look at music. To add to this: Im perfectly happy to pay a premium price for software when I need a new version. Which is also true for 1Password (and LastPass AFAIK). > So no matter if it's in Dropbox, 1Password's servers, or your own hard drive, if anyone obtains a copy of the password file they still have to crack it before they gain access to anything. Bitwarden is right there waiting for you. If I buy a piece of software, it's not unreasonable to expect it to work for some period of time after the purchase. Basically just like Dropbox. It requires a 1Password membership and a 64-bit version of Windows 10 or later. So, whats the problem? So I hope you can give like 2-3 examples on bad and 2-3 on good? I mean, I've only paid Apple _once_ for Logic Pro and have been getting upgrade after upgrade for no cost -- a nice bonus, but I'd be perfectly happy if logic's code had been set in stone at the moment of purchase, too.